ADHD medication: short-term help or long-term gain?

ADHD medication has no positive long-term effects on children’s academic performance. That is the conclusion of Katherine Sharpe, who reviewed earlier studies on the effects of such medication. Her research was recently published in the scientific journal Nature.


Medications such as Ritalin and Concerta can greatly reduce ADHD symptoms. They are therefore widely prescribed to children diagnosed with ADHD. The medications help them calm down and concentrate better in class, which initially improves academic performance. But whether the medications lead to lasting improvements in learning, as manufactureres claim, remains questionable.

Earlier Research

Many of the studies cited in the article show that improvements in school performance from ADHD medication are temporary and do not guarantee higher achievements in the long term. Adults who were medicated as children for ADHD symptoms do not perform better than those who were not. After just one. year, there is almost no difference in grades or social skills between children with and without medication. In the few studies that do show long-term effects, the improvement asre small and statistically insignificant. The gap between children with and without ADHD remains.

According to our expert

Jan Buitelaar, professor of child and adolescent psychiatry at the Donders Institute, confirms Sharpe’s conclusion: “The effects of medication on cognition and learning performance are limited and inconsistent. They primarily improve task orientation and verbal behavior. Children function better: they move less, are less easily distracted, and may complete more assignments. But the level of performance is not necessarily better or higher.”

More than concentration

Katherine Sharpe stresses that children’s lower academic performance with ADHD is not only due to concentration problems. Medication may improve attention span, but it does not address other issues such as learning disorders. In tasks that require flexible thinking rather than focus, medication is of little help.

This is a translation of a repost fromΒ Donders Wonders, the Dutch blog about Brains and Science. The translation was made with help of ChatGPT and adjusted by the original author.

Sources

Nature News Feature


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *